What does "Match Existing" Really Mean?

What We Mean by “Match Existing” and Why It Matters

In a home with history, every detail has a purpose. The trim that frames your windows and the baseboards that hug the floors weren’t just picked from a catalog. They were a product of the era and, over time, became the story of that home.

So when we say "match existing," we don’t mean "match kind-of," and there certainly isn't an option for "close-enough." We mean carefully, intentionally, and respectfully recreating what’s already there so the new feels like it’s always belonged.

What Does “Match Existing” Really Mean?

Here’s how we define it:

Same Species: If your original woodwork is quarter-sawn oak, we’ll use quarter-sawn oak. Not poplar. Not MDF with a faux grain. Different wood species age differently, absorb stain differently, and carry different visual weight. To truly match, it has to be the same.

Same Profile: We don’t settle for “off the shelf” approximations. We trace and replicate the original shapes, curves, and angles. Whether that means creating custom knife profiles or making a few extra passes through the planer, the goal is for your eye not to catch the transition.

Same Finish: Matching the color is just the start. We consider patina, sheen, and how the wood has aged over time. Sometimes, we even mimic the gentle wear of decades past. It’s not just about being new; it’s about belonging.

Same Installation Detail: We match not only materials but also craftsmanship. The mitered corners, the scarf joints, and the shadow lines all matter. Every cut, every return, and every joint is significant.

Take a look at this 1950s-era miter. A quick solution for trimming windows like these—especially if they’re getting painted or stained—might be a simple 45° miter all the way through the profile. But that shortcut wouldn’t match the rest of the home’s original trim joints. To most, it might seem fine, but we’re not aiming for "fine." We’re aiming for craftsmanship that honors the whole home.

Check out the video below for details on this specific trim.

When Not Matching is the Right Call

We’ll always lead with preservation first; that’s the heart of our work. But honesty matters too. The reality is that matching existing trim perfectly can sometimes cost more. Custom knives, specialty woods, and hand-applied finishes add time and expense.

In some projects, we help clients find smart alternatives. Maybe we match the most visible elements and simplify elsewhere. Or perhaps we step away from the original entirely to align with a larger renovation vision, a tighter budget, or to start a new story.

Some clients choose to intentionally update trim during a phased renovation. For example, they may slowly shift to a cleaner, more modern profile as other rooms are remodeled. And that’s perfectly valid too.

Our role is to offer options, honor the home’s story, and help you choose the path that feels most aligned with both your vision and your budget.

The Importance of Craftsmanship

Craftsmanship is at the core of what we do. It’s not just about making things look good; it’s about creating something that lasts. Each piece we create is a testament to the skills and dedication of our craftsmen.

When we match existing elements, we ensure that every detail is executed with precision. This dedication to quality means that your home will not only look beautiful but will also stand the test of time.

The Bottom Line

When we say "match existing," we mean it wholeheartedly. And when we suggest an alternative, we do so thoughtfully, with full transparency, respect for the home’s character, and your long-term goals in mind. Because we believe your home deserves intention in every detail, old or new.

Conclusion

In summary, matching existing elements in your home is about more than just aesthetics. It’s about honoring the history and craftsmanship that has gone into your space. Whether you choose to match every detail or opt for a more modern approach, the key is to make informed decisions that reflect your vision and values.

By understanding the importance of matching existing elements, you can create a home that is not only beautiful but also tells a story. A story that is uniquely yours, woven into the fabric of your living space.

Embrace the journey of home renovation with intention, and let every detail contribute to the narrative of your home.